The Booyzen Archive
An Irishman born at sea, or in Yorkshire, or in Cork

The Barrys

The Barrys gave this family its English forenames, its farm at Manor Owen, its politics — and its single most contradictory record. Everything from 1819 forward is solid. Everything before it falls apart.

John Augustus Barry I, 1819–1903

The most documented person in the Booyzen ancestry, and the least certain.

Born8 June 1819 — recorded in the tree, literally, as "?Sunderland, Durham, England? Ireland? High Seas?"
TradesCarpenter and Builder · timmerman en bouwvakker · Grocer · Labourer — five occupation records, all working trades
Marriedc. 23 February 1846, Dutch Reformed Church, Colesberg — Margaretha Wilhelmina Elizabeth Mary Kolbe
Died3 August 1903 on the farm Manorowen, Barkly East — the tree gives 25 August; his 1915 death notice gives the 3rd. His son James Henry died there too, in 1939, aged 92

The 1915 death notice is now in hand

The tree carried a long research note describing three conflicting documents. One of the three — the 1915 death notice, typewritten and therefore unarguable — turned out to be sitting in the tree's own photo store, unread. It can now be quoted rather than paraphrased.

Typewritten 1915 death notice for John Barry of Barkly East.
Death Notice of John Barry, prepared at Barkly East and signed by his second son James H. Barry, 29 March 1915. Full transcription →
Birthplace and nationality "At sea (exact whereabouts unknown), British."
FatherJohn Barry (address unknown)
MotherBarry, born Neagle — Christian names and address unknown
OccupationCarpenter and builder
ResidenceManorowen, Barkly East District — and he owned no immovable property
Place of last marriage"Burghersdorp (probably)" — the informant was not sure
"Manorowen" is one word, and it is Welsh. The tree renders the farm "Manor Owen", which hides it. Manorowen is a village in Pembrokeshire. A Welsh farm-name on a supposedly Irish family's holding in the north-eastern Cape is a completely unexplored thread — and he did not own the place.

Three answers to one question

An extended research note carried in the tree — written by an earlier researcher, not by this archive — sets out why nobody knows where he was born. The 1915 document above is the second of the three.

Death certificate, 1903

"An Irishman born in Ireland"

Recorded by the Cape Mounted Rifles, then the authority in the district, stationed at Johnson's Leap — and dated two months after his death.

Document, 29 March 1915

"At sea, exact whereabouts unknown. British."

Signed by his second son James Henry Barry. It also names his father as John Barry and his mother's maiden name as "Neagle" — almost certainly Nagle, of County Cork.

The tree's own guess

Sunderland, Durham

Offered with a question mark and no source. The note's own conclusion is a question: if he was born on the high seas with the 1820 Settlers, who were his parents?

The 1820 Settler hypothesis does not survive arithmetic. He was born 8 June 1819. The settler fleets sailed from late 1819 and reached Algoa Bay from April 1820. He cannot have been born on that voyage. But the family does have a documented 1820 Settler — his own father-in-law, George Augustus Kolbe, who sailed on the Nautilus from Gravesend on 3 December 1819. Inferred The likeliest reading is that a true settler story attached itself to the wrong branch. The Kolbes →

The line that makes the rebel story make sense

"As an Irishman, John Barry was reputed to be anti English, and as his son and grandson were married to Dutch girls their activity during the Boer War would be interesting."

From the same research note in the tree. Written by someone else, about their own family, long before this archive existed.

It lands exactly on the Booyzen name-change testimony. His daughter Kathleen Barry married Willem Hermanus Booyzen — the man recorded as changing Booysen to Booyzen so as not to be taken for a British-siding joiner. An anti-English Irish grandfather at Barkly East, whose children married almost entirely into Cape Dutch families, is precisely the household in which rebel sympathies would be unremarkable.

Inferred This is the most testable inference in the archive, and it is still an inference. Nobody has yet found a Barry or a Booysen on a rebel roll. The rebels →

He married into Afrikanerdom, not the other way round

An English-speaking carpenter of Irish reputation married a Cape-born woman in the Dutch Reformed Church at Colesberg, and within one generation his children had married Louw, van Ellinckhuyzen, Schoemann, Dry, Bedford — and Booyzen.

ChildDatesBornMarried
John Augustus II1847–1935Burgersdorpm. Alida Jacoba van Ellinckhuyzen, 1870, DRC Colesberg
James Henry1848–1939Burgersdorpm. Maria Margaretha Hester Catherina Louw, 1867, Dordrecht; died at Manor Owen aged 92
George Augustus1850–1933Burgersdorp
Margaretha Louisa Maria (Bedford)1851–1915Burgersdorpm. Thomas Bedford, 1875, Colesberg
Catherina Maria Sophia1855–1859Burgersdorpdied aged four, 30 July 1859
Hendrik Nicholaas1857–1931Dordrechtm. Anna Johanna Maria Schoemann, 1877, Barkly East
Catherine Maria Sophia “Kathleen”1859–1940Barkly Eastm. Willem Hermanus Booyzen, 1879 — the line to David
Willem Frederick Thomas “Tom”1861–1890Barkly Eastm. Hendrina Petronella Jacomina Dry, 1886; died at 29
Frederick Fortunatus1863–1952Burgersdorpthe forename reappears as Frederik Fortsenatus Booÿsen, 1899
Richard Peter1866–1946Lady Grey
— (a duplicate)the tree also lists a “Kathleen Mary Barry (Booysen)”. The 1915 death notice shows she is the same woman as Kathleen above. Withdrawn.
Read rows five and seven together. Catherina Maria Sophia Barry died on 30 July 1859. Catherine Maria Sophia Barry was born on 4 August 1859 — five days later, and was given the dead child's name. That name then travelled: to Catherine Mary Sophia Booyzen (1891–1946), and to Catherine Mary Sophia Booyzen (1929–2013), David Defranceski's grandmother. A four-year-old's death in Burgersdorp is still being commemorated, unknowingly, four generations later.

One sister fewer than the tree thinks

The tree lists Catherine Maria Sophia "Kathleen" Barry (1859–1940), married Booyzen and, separately, a sister Kathleen Mary Barry (Booysen) with no dates — implying two Barry sisters married two Booysens.

The 1915 death notice lists only one Barry daughter married to a Boyson: "Kathleen Mary Boyson, born Barry, married in community of property to William Boyson." And the arithmetic closes exactly — the tree's 11 children equal the notice's 8 surviving, plus the 2 who predeceased him (Catherina Maria Sophia, d. 1859; Willem Frederick Thomas, d. 1890), plus 1 duplicate.

Resolved They are the same woman. This archive's earlier claim of "two Barry sisters married Booysens" is withdrawn.

The third Barry–Booyzen tie stands: Dorothea Regina Barry married Henry James Booyzen at Elliot in 1912. The cousin marriage →

Kathleen Barry, 1859–1940

Born at Barkly East, christened at Dordrecht in September 1859. Her occupation is recorded — rarely, and valuably — as "Needle Woman". She married Willem Hermanus Booyzen on 22 December 1879 and bore thirteen children, of whom nine are dated.

She outlived her husband by thirty-five years and died on 5 September 1940 at No. 1, Fifteenth Avenue, Mayfair, Johannesburg, of carcinoma of the uterus after thirteen months' illness. She was buried at Brixton Cemetery. She made the journey the testimony describes, and lived four decades on the Rand at the end of it.

Her death certificate records her occupation as Home Duties — and, on the line below, "Military Pensioner." Her husband had been dead thirty-five years and died of an ulcer, so the pension is not his.

Searched The archive guessed a son killed in the First World War. The war-dead registers say otherwise: no Booyzen among the 1914–18 dead, no Booysen matching a son's forename, and all her identifiable sons survived — dying in 1932, 1952, 1956, 1966 and 1980. The pension belongs to a man who served and came home. Where it goes next →

Nine years after her death, her granddaughter and namesake Catherine Mary Sophia Booyzen married at St Joseph's Catholic Church, Mayfair. Johannesburg →

Barkly East, off the index

Ranking a whole-surname search by place brings the right Barrys to the top. These are index entries and not documents, and the person pages say so — but they name three farms, date a man this archive had dateless, and produce one name that does a great deal of work.

WhoDatesWhat the index says
Richard Pieter Kolbe Barryb. 1899 Both names at once. Richard Pieter for the Barry of Manorowen, Kolbe for the 1820 Settler family his great-grandmother married out of. Married Maria Magdalena Siebert.
James Henry Barryc. 1847 – 23 Jun 1939 He swore his father's 1915 death notice. Now dated: dead at Barkly East, having outlived his father by thirty-six years.
Harriet Louisa Barry1894 – 7 Sep 1912 Of Manorowen, Barkly East district — R. P. Barry's farm. Dead at eighteen.
Cornelia Herculena Petronella Barryd. 21 Dec 1909 Of Cherryville, Barkly East — a third named Barry farm, after Manorowen and Jerpoint.
John Gerson Eliazer Barry1893 – 8 Mar 1941 Married Elizabeth Johanna Magdalena Botha; died at Barkly East.
Theunis Christoffel Barry1895 – 11 Jul 1963 Born Barkly East, died East London.

Richard Pieter Kolbe Barry is the one that matters. A Barry born in 1899 carrying both the forename of the man on the Cape Rebel roll and the surname of the 1820 Settler family this archive has spent weeks documenting. It does not prove the rebel is Kathleen's brother. It does show that whoever named this child was standing inside the same family this archive is describing. The namesakes →

How far the Barry names travel

There is no Barry surname left in this family after 1859. There is a great deal of Barry name.

Eleven Daschner children listed on a 1942 death notice, several carrying Barry and Booyzen forenames.
The children of Catharina Maria Sophia Booysen — Kathleen Barry's daughter — on her husband's 1942 death notice.

Kathleen Barry married a Booyzen in the 1880s, so the surname stops with her. Her daughter married a Daschner, so it is two surnames gone in two generations. Then look at what those eleven grandchildren are called:

  • Catherine Mary Sophia Daschner — Kathleen's own name, third generation running
  • Margaret Wilhelmina Elizabeth Jeanette Daschner — the Barry name that also runs down the Pretorius side of this family and reaches Maggie Booyzen in 1926
  • Richard Peter Daschner — for Kathleen's brother Richard Peter Barry of Manorowen
  • Henry James Daschner — for her brother Henry James Booyzen
  • William Herman Daschner — for her father Willem Hermanus
Five of eleven. The Barrys stop being a surname in this archive in 1859 and go on being a set of first names for another eighty years.

And a sixth, off the 1942 list The Johannesburg cemetery index carries a George Downing Daschner, buried at Brixton on 20 June 1925, the year he was born. He is not on his father's death notice because he was dead seventeen years before it was written — a twelfth child. George Downing is the name of Kathleen Barry's own grandson, born in 1901, and here it is on an infant in another family in the same decade. A second of the name died in 1998.

This comes from an index and not from an image, and the page says so. But it moves the reading: six names, not five, and a pattern that cannot comfortably be called coincidence. The namesakes →

This matters to the rebel question in a small, real way. When the Cape Rebel roll produces a Fred J. Barry of Ivanhoe and a Richard Peter Barry of Jerpoint, the second name is not a coincidence to be waved at — it is a name this family demonstrably used and kept using. It still does not prove the man on the roll is Kathleen's brother, and this archive still marks that unproven. But it does mean the name is evidence of a family, not of an individual. The 1942 notice →

Not one of them is in the Master's index

Film 007844477 is the Cape Master's own Index of Estates 1834–1912 — every estate reported in the Colony for seventy-eight years, alphabetically, with the death-notice number beside each name. Barry runs across three pages and this family is on none of them.

Page 232 of the Cape Master's Index of Estates: Barry, A to H.
232 — A to H. Two Fredericks, Johannes and William. No Fortunatus.
Page 233 of the Cape Master's Index of Estates: Barry, H to J.
233 — the Johns. Five plain, then Charles, Daniel, Henry, Henry, Joseph, William. No John Augustus.
Page 234 of the Cape Master's Index of Estates: Barry, M to W, then Barsby.
234 — M to W, then Barsby. Two Richards, 1836 and 1858. No Richard Peter, and no Margaretha at all.

The archive went to this index for one thing: to settle whether the Cape Rebel Richard Peter Barry of Jerpoint is Kathleen's brother, by finding his estate. He is not there. Neither is Frederick Fortunatus, nor Dorothea Regina, nor Hendrik Nicholaas, nor Catherine Maria Sophia, nor Kathleen Mary.

And neither, more startlingly, is John Augustus Barry, who died in August 1903 in the middle of the index's range, or his widow Margaretha Kolbe, who died in 1912, the year it closes.

Then the reason arrives, and it is not an absence at all. This archive has already read their death notices. Both are dated 29 March 1915, sworn by their sons. The index stops in 1912. They filed in 1915.

And there is a second reason, found the same afternoon. The FamilySearch index of Cape probate enters John Barry's estate not at Cape Town but at GRAHAMSTOWN — the Master's office of the Eastern Districts. So this volume would not have held him even if he had died in 1911. Two independent reasons for one absence, and the archive had neither of them an hour ago.

John Augustus Barry died in August 1903 and nobody reported his estate for twelve years. That is not carelessness with a form. It is the third instance of the same thing in this archive:

WhoDiedReportedGapWho filed
John Augustus Barry and Margaretha Kolbe1903 · 191229 Mar 191512 yearstwo sons, together
Isabella Fredrika Booyzen, born Coetzee31 Mar 19301 Apr 194313 yearsher husband
Maria Louisa Bertha Mountjoy, born Kumm3 Jul 193419 Feb 19383½ yearsher son — "death not reported"

Three families, three decades, one habit. Twice a husband's estate and a wife's were filed on the same day, years after the fact, by a son. The Master's office was something this family went to when it had to, not when somebody died — and any search that assumes an estate was reported in the year of the death will miss them all. Two of this archive's own corrections are exactly that mistake →

And then it breaks

Above John Augustus Barry I the record becomes impossible. His recorded father, John Barry (1796–1853), is buried in Yorkshire five days before he dies in the Eastern Cape. His parents are entered as "Unknown Barry" and "Unknown Barry"; a brother as "Other Barry's - South Africa Barry".

The Barry line is documented from 1819 forward and is a knot before it. The archive draws it as a break, not a chain. See the full contradiction →