Charlotte Anne Callaghan
ELDEST DAUGHTER OF HUGH CALLAGHAN, ESQ., OF ASHBY MANOR, district of Queenstown; married Charles Andrew Werdmuller on 13 February 1884. SEVEN YEARS LATER SHE WAS DEAD AT THIRTY-TWO, at Hoopstad, “after a long illness”, and a correspondent’s obituary in the Queenstown Free Press adds that she had arrived there only a few months before, in indifferent health, with a disorder of the heart that proved organic. SHE LEFT “A HUSBAND AND TWO LITTLE GIRLS”, and it is that line which lets the 1909 marriage notice call Amy a second daughter.
Every record naming Charlotte Anne Callaghan →
No family is drawn here, because none is recorded. This archive holds Charlotte Anne Callaghan as a name on a document — a witness at a font, a signature on a form, a person named in someone else's list — and has no record of who their parents, spouse or children were. That is a statement about the sources, not about the person. Every record naming them →
The record
| Name | Charlotte Anne Callaghan |
| Born | c. 1859 |
| Died | 17 Feb 1891, Hoopstad, Orange Free State — aged 32 |
| Line | Kolbe |
| Confidence | Documented |
What the archive holds
ELDEST DAUGHTER OF HUGH CALLAGHAN, ESQ., OF ASHBY MANOR, district of Queenstown; married Charles Andrew Werdmuller on 13 February 1884. SEVEN YEARS LATER SHE WAS DEAD AT THIRTY-TWO, at Hoopstad, “after a long illness”, and a correspondent’s obituary in the Queenstown Free Press adds that she had arrived there only a few months before, in indifferent health, with a disorder of the heart that proved organic. SHE LEFT “A HUSBAND AND TWO LITTLE GIRLS”, and it is that line which lets the 1909 marriage notice call Amy a second daughter.
Everyone
…The Queenstown Free Press of 13 February 1884 marries “CHARLES ANDREW WERDMULLER, OF STEYNSBURG, SECOND SON OF THE LATE C.J.O. WERDMULLER, OF BURGHERSDORP” to Charlotte Anne Callaghan. A man born 14 February 1857 was twenty-seven that week. NOT PROVED: no document read here names Charles Andrew’s mother, and his father — or a man of exactly that name — married again at Burgersdorp in 1874. NAMELESS IN THE INDEX, AND THAT IS THE POINT.…
A.M. Kolbe of Piet Retief
…OF HOOPSTAD, O.R.C.” One of the two little girls her mother left in 1891.… A.M. Kolbe of Piet Retief …Feb 1884 Charles Andrew Werdmuller SECOND SON OF THE LATE C.J.O. WERDMULLER OF BURGHERSDORP, married at W Charlotte Anne Callaghan c.… Angeline Kolbe …Kolbe of Piet Retief 23 Feb 1836 – 7 Jan 1913, Piet Retief A.M. Kolbe of Piet Retief 4 May 1843 – 21 Sep 1907, Piet Retief P.J.…
A Werdmuller child of 1857
…The Queenstown Free Press of 13 February 1884 marries “CHARLES ANDREW WERDMULLER, OF STEYNSBURG, SECOND SON OF THE LATE C.J.O. WERDMULLER, OF BURGHERSDORP” to Charlotte Anne Callaghan. A man born 14 February 1857 was twenty-seven that week. NOT PROVED: no document read here names Charles Andrew’s mother, and his father — or a man of exactly that name — married again at Burgersdorp in 1874. NAMELESS IN THE INDEX, AND THAT IS THE POINT.…
Abel Hermanus Gerhardus Lowies
…en · b.… Everyone …He outlived that uncle by sixty-eight years. The Rustenburg register Namesakes Anna Catharina Booysen Documented 135 mentions 21 Sep 1842 bef.… Abel Hermanus Gerhardus Lowies …chner …tate 7081 The 1… Anna Francisa Roos ….… Abel Hermanus Gerhardus Lowies …Her 190… Angeline Kolbe …WERDMULLER OF BURGHERSDORP, married at W Charlotte Anne Callaghan c.… Angeline Kolbe …1872 15 Nov 1900, Wakkerstroom — aged 28 A WOMAN OF THIS NAME DIES AT WAKKERSTROOM IN THE MIDDLE OF THE WAR, and this archive cannot say who she is.… Anna Catharina Booysen …e only one who is no Johan Gottlie… Anna Catharina Botha …A fourth Botha marriage in this archive, and none of them yet joined to another.… Abel Hermanus Gerhardus Lowies …ised 10 Apr 18… Abel Hermanus Ger…
Adriana Christina Viljoen
…archive, and none of them yet joined to another.… Adriana Christina Viljoen …d Daschner …van Ellinckhuizen …at all until the index was… Amelia A.… Aletta Catharina Johanna Venter …bert Alfred Daschner …tate 7081 The 1… Anna Francisa Roos ….… Abel Hermanus Gerhardus Lowies …Her 190… Angeline Kolbe …WERDMULLER OF BURGHERSDORP, married at W Charlotte Anne Callaghan c.… Angeline Kolbe …1872 15 Nov 1900, Wakkerstroom — aged 28 A WOMAN OF THIS NAME DIES AT WAKKERSTROOM IN THE… Anna Catharina Booysen …F BURGHERSDORP, married at W Charlotte Anne Callaghan c.… Angeline Kolbe …1872 15 Nov 1900, Wakkerstroom — aged 28 A WOMAN OF THIS NAME DIES AT WAKKERSTROOM IN THE MIDDLE OF THE WAR, and this archive cannot say who she is.… Anna Catharina Booysen …e only one who i…
Adriana Henrietta Johanna Kolbe
…na Johanna Maria Booijsen Documented 84 mentions — — Third of the seven children on the 1891 Sterfkennis, of age by then and not traced since.… Anna Francisa Roos …The only son-in-law on the page.… Anna J.… Anna Jacoba van der Merwe …Feb 1884 Charles Andrew Werdmuller SECOND SON OF THE LATE C.J.O. WERDMULLER OF BURGHERSDORP, married at W Charlotte Anne Callaghan c.… A Werdmuller child of 1857 …be Godfather at the Burgersdorp font on 23 October 1853, standing for his George Kolbe Godfath… Adriana Henrietta Johanna Kolbe …hanna Kolbe …Gottlieb Pretorius …n 1854, ind… Anna J.… Others on the Kolbe side Margaretha Wilhelmina Elizabeth Mary Kolbe 1826 – 2 Aug 1912, Manorowen, Barkly East — estate 1291 A Werdmuller child of 1857 14 Feb 1857, baptised 10 Apr 185…
Aletta Catharina Johanna Venter
…archive, and none of them yet joined to another.… Adriana Christina Viljoen …d Daschner …van Ellinckhuizen …at all until the index was… Amelia A.… Aletta Catharina Johanna Venter …bert Alfred Daschner …tate 7081 The 1… Anna Francisa Roos ….… Abel Hermanus Gerhardus Lowies …Her 190… Angeline Kolbe …WERDMULLER OF BURGHERSDORP, married at W Charlotte Anne Callaghan c.… Angeline Kolbe …1872 15 Nov 1900, Wakkerstroom — aged 28 A WOMAN OF THIS NAME DIES AT WAKKERSTROOM IN THE MIDDLE OF THE WAR, and this archive cannot say who she is.… Anna Catharina Booysen …e only one who is n… Anna Catharina Booysen …Cat… Adriana Christina Viljoen …Anna Catharina Booysen Document… Al… Others on the Kolbe side Margaretha Wilhelmina Elizabeth Mary Kolbe 1826 – 2 Aug 1912, Mano…
Amelia A. Kolbe
…The groom is not in the index this archive read and she is the only one of the three sisters who can currently be followed out of the house.… …WERDMULLER OF BURGHERSDORP, married at W Charlotte Anne Callaghan c.… Adriana Henrietta Johanna Kolbe …Feb 1884 Charles Andrew Werdmuller SECOND SON OF THE LATE C.J.O. WERDMULLER OF BURGHERSDORP, married at W Charlotte Anne Callaghan c.… Amelia A. Kolbe …Feb 1884 Charles Andrew Werdmuller SECOND SON OF THE LATE C.J.O.… Others on the Kolbe side Margaretha Wilhelmina Elizabeth Mary Kolbe 1826 – 2 Aug 1912, Manorowen, Barkly East — estate 1291 G.A.…
Amy Werdmuller
…ter …Catharina Olivier …The Documents Aletta Catharina Olivier Documented 85 mentions 15 May 1823, baptised 20 Oct 1823 at Cradock… Aletta Catharina Olivier …ry Kolbe 1826 – 2 Aug 1912, Manorowen, Barkly East — estate… …hers on the Kolbe side Margaretha Wilhelmina Elizabeth Mary K… Amy Werdmuller …WERDMULLER OF BURGHERSDORP, married at W Charlotte Anne Callaghan c.… Andries Gottlieb Pretorius …Barkly East — estate 1291 A Werdmuller child of 1857 14 Feb 1857, baptised 10 Apr 1857 at Burgersdorp – — John Kolbe Godfather at the Burgersdorp font on 23 October 1853, standing for his George Kolbe Godfather at the same font, the same day.… Amelia A. Kolbe …umented 124 mentions 2… Andries Gottlie… Alida Jacoba van Ellinckhuizen …Dec 1924 at Vereeniging aged eigh…
Andries Gottlieb Pretorius
…on 15 November 1900.… Adriana Christina Viljoen …Abel Hermanus Gerhardus Lowies …Kolbe …AND SHE MARRIED: Amelia Ann Kolbe, at ST PANCRAS in 1854, indexed twice.… A… Andries Gottlieb Pretorius …archive had John Augu… Amelia A.… Adriana Henrietta Johanna Kolbe …has moved from Burge… Amy Werdmuller …WERDMULLER OF BURGHERSDORP, married at W Charlotte Anne Callaghan c.… Andries Gottlieb Pretorius …… …The household has moved from Burgersdorp to Dord… Andries Gottlieb Pretorius …ieb Pretorius …ly be followed out of the… Albert Alfred Daschner …rothy Daschner Documented 106 mentions 20… Alett… Adriana Henrietta Johanna Kolbe …s …e Women The Cousin Marriag… Amy Werdmuller …1859 – 17 Feb 1891, Hoopstad, Orange Free State — aged 32 Amy Werdmuller “MARTINEAU — WERD…
Angeline Kolbe
…Kolbe …e.… Adriana Henri… Angeline Kolbe …at… Adriana Christina Vil… Abel Hermanus Gerhardus Lowies …Disputed Errands Sources What… Adriana Christina Viljoen …Namesakes Catherine Mary Sophia Barry of 1855 Documented 21 mentions 10 Jul 1855, baptised 22 Jul 1855 at Burgersdorp bef.… Amy Werdmuller …WERDMULLER OF BURGHERSDORP, married at W Charlotte Anne Callaghan c.… Andries Gottlieb Pretorius …be Godfather at the Burgersdorp font on 23… Amelia A. Kolbe …FROM THE CENSUS AND THE MARRIAGE INDEX.… A Werdmuller child of 1857 …Kolbe …AND SHE MARRIED: Amelia Ann Kolbe, at ST PANCRAS in 1854, indexed twice.… …Dec 1924 at Vereeniging aged eighteen, with parental c… …Kolbe …e.… Adriana Henri… Angeline Kolbe …at… Adriana Christina Viljoen …Anna Catharina Booysen Do…
Anna Catharina Booysen
…0 Apr 1857 at Burgersdorp – — John Kolbe Godfather at the Burgersdorp font on 23 October 1853, standing for his George Kolbe Godfather at the same font, the same day.… Amelia A.… Angeline Kolbe …chner …tate 7081 The 1… Anna Francisa Roos ….… Abel Hermanus Gerhardus Lowies …Her 190… Angeline Kolbe …WERDMULLER OF BURGHERSDORP, married at W Charlotte Anne Callaghan c.… Angeline Kolbe …1872 15 Nov 1900, Wakkerstroom — aged 28 A WOMAN OF THIS NAME DIES AT WAKKERSTROOM IN THE MIDDLE OF THE WAR, and this archive cannot say who she is.… Anna Catharina Booysen …e only one who is no Johan Gottlieb Kolbe…… Anna Francisa Roos …arental consent.… Anna Cat… Adriana Christina Viljoen …Anna Catharina Booy… Adriana Christina Viljoen …melia A.… Aletta Catharina Johanna Ven…
Anna Catharina Mountjoy
…na Catharina Grobelaar …2 Aug 1912, Manorowen, Barkly Ea… Anna Catharina J… Anna Catharina Mountjoy …tificate says they had.… A Werdmuller child of 1857 …e of the two little girls her mother left in 1891.… A Werdmuller child of 1857 …Feb 1884 Charles Andrew Werdmuller SECOND SON OF THE LATE C.J.O. WERDMULLER OF BURGHERSDORP, married at W Charlotte Anne Callaghan c.… Andries Gottlieb Pretorius …lbert Alfred Daschner …h parental consent.… Anna Catharina Booysen …4 Dec 1855 Jacoba Catharina… Anna… Anna Catharina Botha …Parents Ockert Johannes Stephanus Olivier record Anna Catharina Botha record Anna Catharina Johanna Olivier 10 Sep 1824 – 9 May 1891 Booyzen married Hendrik Stefanus Booijsen c.… Anna Catharina Grobelaar …vier …d S.… …Sterfkennis 6361: landbo…
Anna Catharina Sleer
…na Johan… Alida Eduarda Barry …r …van Ellinckhuizen …at all until th… Alida Jacoba van Ellinckhuizen …p 1842… Anna Catharina Johanna Olivier …ay 1891 Ockert Johannes Stephanus Olivier… Andries Gottlieb Pretorius …uller child of 1857 …Feb 1884 Charles Andrew Werdmuller SECOND SON OF THE LATE C.J.O. WERDMULLER OF BURGHERSDORP, married at W Charlotte Anne Callaghan c.… Andries Gottlieb Pretorius …lbert Alfred Daschner …h parental consent.… Anna Catharina Booysen …4 Dec 1855 Jacoba Catharina… Anna Catharina Mountjoy …joy Documented 79 mentions 5 Aug… Anna Catharina Sleer …phia Benadie …f 1894 Documented 35 m… Anna Catharina Sophia Benadie …cumen… Anna Francisa Roos …ary Kolbe 1826 – 2 Aug 1912, Manorowen, Barkly East — estate 1291 A Werdmuller child of 1857…
Anna Catharina Sophia Benadie
……Olivier …s baptis… Adriana Henrietta Johanna Kolbe …baptism.… Alida Jacoba va… Albert Alfred Daschner …ism.… Alida Jacoba van Ellinckhuizen …This archive had John Augustus II as a name… Andries Gottli… Anna Catharina Botha …Olivier Documented… Andries Gottlieb Pretorius …ND SON OF THE LATE C.J.O. WERDMULLER OF BURGHERSDORP, married at W Charlotte Anne Callaghan c.… Andries Gottlieb Pretorius …lbert Alfred Daschner …h parental consent.… Anna Catharina Booysen …4 Dec 1855 Jacoba Catharina… Anna Catharina Mountjoy …joy Documented 79 mentions 5 Aug… Anna Catharina Sleer …phia Benadie …f 1894 Documented 35 m… Anna Catharina Sophia Benadie …cumen… Anna Francisa Roos …ary Kolbe 1826 – 2 Aug 1912, Manorowen, Barkly East — estate 1291 A Werdmuller child of 1857…
Anna Francisa Roos
…archive, and none of them yet joined to another.… Adriana Christina Viljoen …d Daschner …van Ellinckhuizen …at all until the index was… Amelia A.… Aletta Catharina Johanna Venter …bert Alfred Daschner …tate 7081 The 1… Anna Francisa Roos ….… Abel Hermanus Gerhardus Lowies …Her 190… Angeline Kolbe …WERDMULLER OF BURGHERSDORP, married at W Charlotte Anne Callaghan c.… Angeline Kolbe …1872 15 Nov 1900, Wakkerstroom — aged 28 A WOMAN OF THIS NAME DIES AT WAKKERSTROOM IN THE MIDDLE OF THE WAR, and this archive cannot say who she is.… Anna Catharina Booysen …e only one who is no Johan Gottlieb Kolbe…… Anna Francisa Roos …arental consen… Anna Catharina Booysen …THE MIDDLE OF THE WAR, and this archive cannot say who she is.… Anna Catharina Booysen …4 Dec 1855 Ja…
Anna J. Mary Booyzen
…he Barrys The Kolbes The Women The Cousin Marriage The work The Documents The Plates The Namesakes People & places The People The Register Households Marriages Places Evidence Disputed Errands Sources What… Anna Jacoba van der Merwe …Feb 1884 Charles Andrew Werdmuller SECOND SON OF THE LATE C.J.O. WERDMULLER OF BURGHERSDORP, married at W Charlotte Anne Callaghan c.… A Werdmuller child of 1857 …be Godfather at the Burgersdorp font on 23 October 1853, standing for his George Kolbe Godfath… Adriana Henrietta Johanna Kolbe …hanna Kolbe …Gottlieb Pretorius …n 1854, ind… Anna J.… Anna Johanna Maria Booijsen …eb Kolbe…… Anna Francisa Roos …arental consent.… Anna Cat… Adriana Christina Viljoen …Anna Catharina Booysen Document… Adriana Henrietta Johanna Kolbe …ho…
Anna Jacoba van der Merwe
…age.… Anna J.… Anna Jacoba van der Merwe …Named only in her husband's obituary; this archive has no birth, no death and no parents for her, and she is the third van der Merwe to marry into these families.… A Werdmuller child of 1857 …Feb 1884 Charles Andrew Werdmuller SECOND SON OF THE LATE C.J.O. WERDMULLER OF BURGHERSDORP, married at W Charlotte Anne Callaghan c.… Adriana Henrietta Johanna Kolbe …Feb 1884 Charles Andrew Werdmuller SEC… Adriana Henrietta Johanna Kolbe …his archive printed for an afternoon.… Albert Alfred Daschner …44 His wife, married 30… …The household has moved from Burgersdorp to Dordrecht by this baptism.… Alida Jacoba… Albert Alfred Daschner …from BillionGr… Anna Catharina Booysen …l conse… Aletta Catharina Johanna Venter …… Anna E…
Anna Johanna Maria Booijsen
…omen Anna Johanna Maria Booijsen Documented 78 mentions — — Third of the seven children on the 1891 Sterfkennis, of age by then and not traced since.… Anna Francisa Roos …Fernando Lerena Docum… Anna Francisa Roos …1924 1971 Her husband, married 15 Jan 1949 at St Joseph's, Mayfair.… A Werdmuller child of 1857 …F BURGHERSDORP, married at W Charlotte Anne Callaghan c.… Andries Gottlieb Pretorius …lbert Alfred Daschner …h parental c… Anna Catharina Sophia Benadie …a Johanna Olivier …lk Booyzen of 1940 also wr… Anna Catharina Mountjoy …as NOT KNOWN — the oldest documen… Anna Catharina Sleer …Married James Montjoy 9 Mar 1817 at Graaff-Reinet, having first been the widow of William Pietersen.… Anna Catharina Sophia Benadie …f 1894 Documented 32 mentio… Anna Eli…
Anna Johanna Maria Booyzen (Vermaak)
…named for her grandmother ANNA MARIA VAN DER MERWE — the second document in this archive to carry that name forward.… Adriana Henrietta Johanna Kolbe …vables only and not above… Albert Alfred Daschner …, and none of… Albert Alfred Daschn… Alida Eduarda Barry …Alida Eduarda Barry …dus Lowies …Kolb… Amy Werdmuller …GHERSDORP, married at W Charlotte Anne Callaghan c.… Amy Werdmuller …Feb 1884 Charles Andrew Werdmuller SECOND SON OF THE LATE C.J.O. WERDMULLER OF BURGHERSDORP, married at W Charlotte Anne Callaghan c.… Angeline Kolbe …Feb 1884 Charles Andrew Werdmuller SECOND SON OF THE LATE C.J.O.… Anna Susanna Booijzen …lesberg — Fifth of the eight.… Anna Johanna Maria Booyzen (Vermaak) …r ANNA MARIA VAN DER MERWE — the second document in this archive to ca…
Anna Johanna Maria Pretorius
…archive cannot say who she is.… Andries Gottlieb Pretorius …The Documents Anna Johanna Maria Pretorius Documented 93 mentions 3 Oct 1906 1944 His wife, married 30 Dec 1924 at Vereeniging aged eighteen, with parental consent.…… …s Cath… Adriana Henrietta Johanna Kolbe …ina Elizabe… Amy Werdmuller …WERDMULLER OF BURGHERSDORP, married at W Charlotte Anne Callaghan c.… Andries Gottlieb Pretorius …rhardus Lowies …Her 1902 death notice Nuno Fernando Lerena Documented 44 mentions 1924 1971 Her husband, m… Andries Gottlieb Pretorius …A zinc building in Market Street Namesakes Andries Gottlieb Pretorius Documented 71 mentions — — Third witness at the 1870 font, and presumably the bride's people — the only trace the archive has of Johanna Margaritha Pretorius's o…
Anna Johanna Maria Schoeman
…12.… Anna Susanna Booijzen …13 Aug 1889 inferred FROM THE INDEX — no image has been read,… Aubrey Diesel …12. 2.… Anna Johanna Maria Schoeman …2.… Anna Maria Booijsen of 1835 …10 Dec 1886 inferred Miny Barry b.… Aubrey Diesel …12. 2.… Augustus Kolbe Enslin …WERDMULLER OF BURGHERSDORP, married at W Charlotte Anne Callaghan c.… Catharina Maria Louisa Kolbe …Feb 1884 Charles Andrew Werdmuller SECOND SON OF THE LATE C.J.O. WERDMULLER OF BURGHERSDORP, married at W Charlotte Anne Callaghan c.… Catharine Sophia Maria Kolbe …Feb 1884 Charles Andrew Werdmuller SECOND SON OF THE LATE C.J.O.… Anna Johanna Maria Schoeman …12.…
Anna Maria van der Merwe
…Adriana Henrietta Johanna Kolbe …rd godparen…… Adriana Henr… Albert Alfred Daschner …cuments Aletta Catharina Olivier Documented 73 mentions 15 May 1823, bapti… Aletta Catharina Johanna Venter …The 1891 notices 7 children Petrus Jacobus Booysen of Rustenburg · 20 Apr 1851 – bef.… Amy Werdmuller …. WERDMULLER OF BURGHERSDORP, married at W Charlotte Anne Callaghan c.… Angeline Kolbe …Feb 1884 Charles Andrew Werdmuller SECOND SON OF THE LATE C.J.O.… Anna Susanna Booijzen …lesberg — Fifth of the eight.… Anna Johanna Maria Booyzen (Vermaak) …r ANNA MARIA VAN DER MERWE — the second document in this archive to carry that name forward.… Anna Maria van der Merwe …t agree — and this archive has…… Anna Susanna Booijzen …he other one.… Catharina Maria… Aubrey… Other…
Anna Susanna Booijzen
…A zinc building in Market Street The Women Elizabeth Margarietha Booijzen Documented 86 mentions — a minor, bef. 1904 Squeezed in between the lines of her mother's death notice after it had been written, with the words DIED MINOR against her.… Amy Werdmuller …WERDMULLER OF BURGHERSDORP, married at W Charlotte Anne Callaghan c.… Amy Werdmuller …Feb 1884 Charles Andrew Werdmuller SECOND SON OF THE LATE C.J.O.… Anna Eliezabet Booijsen ….… Anna Catharina Sophia Benadie …f 1894 Documented 33 mentio… Anna Eliezabet Booijsen …Sterfkennis, of age by then and not traced since.…
Anna van der Merwe of Burgersdorp
…Kolbe of Piet Retief …Kolbe of Piet Retief Aug 1865 – 28 Nov 1919, Piet Retief John Gerson Eliezar Kolbe 7 Jul 1822, Uitenhage – 3 Apr 1868, the farm Leeuwberg — aged 45 Coenraad Johannes Otto Werdmuller — – bef. Feb 1884 Charles Andrew Werdmuller SECOND SON OF THE LATE C.J.O. WERDMULLER OF BURGHERSDORP, married at W Charlotte Anne Callaghan c.… Anna van der Merwe of Burgersdorp …Kolbe of Piet Retief 23 Feb 1836 – 7 Jan 1913, Piet Retief A.M.…
Aubrey Diesel
…2.… Anna Johanna Maria Schoeman …10 Dec 1886 inferred Miny Barry b.… Aubrey Diesel …The Documents Aubrey Diesel Documented 102 mentions — — Grandson, a minor in 1938; the other half, £10. 12. 2.…
Others on the Kolbe side
All 309 people → · The places → · Search the archive →
A dossier is every mention of a person anywhere in this archive, gathered automatically after the site is built and linked back to the page it appears on. Identity here is by NAME, not by resolved individual — where two people share a name they share this page, and the archive says so rather than guessing. Nothing on a dossier page is new evidence; it is the same evidence, brought together.